Missables checklist

Mining Company Letter to Cornwall

Oil Company Letter to Cornwall

Charles Smith — Hunting

Javier Escuella — Home Robbery

Lenny Summers — Five Finger Fillet

Charity Handbill

Thomas Downes's table in Valentine

Dutch's Speech Notes

Near the broken wagon at Horseshoe Overlook

Money Lending and Other Sins I & II

Pouring Forth Oil II

Source calls out part II specifically; this package tracks I & II as one mission

We Loved Once and True I-III

Antique Watch

Wrobel's house drawer

Errand Boy

Deliver 5 camp requests

Friends with Benefits

Complete a companion activity in each camp

Give to the Poor

Donate $250 to the tithing box

Javier Escuella — Rescue Bill Williamson

Available after "The First Shall be Last"

Letter from St. Luke's Academy

Looted from Appleseed Timber Company workers

Bucket Hat

Worn by Appleseed Timber Company workers

Good, Honest, Snake Oil

A Zoological Compendium of Earth's Creatures

Arthur's tent

Chelonian Handbill

Saint Denis

Letter from Ms. Hobbs

After "A Better World, A New Friend"

Rambles through Woods and Plains

Arthur's tent

Appleseed Timber Company (first 4 stages)

Castor's Ridge (first 4 stages)

Central Union Railroad Camp (first 3 stages)

Classic Raccoon Mountain Hat

From Jon at the Saloon; also known to bug and fail to save into the wardrobe once the Epilogue starts

Newsboy Cap

From enemies during multiple missions/random encounters

Van Horn Mansion

Braithwaite's Secret

Outhouse near the Manor

Arcadia for Amateurs III

Fundraiser

Carolina Parakeet

Study before it goes extinct

Bride Photograph

Jim's corpse near Strawberry

Letter to Edmund from Mother

"American Dreams" stranger mission

Letter to Mayor Timmins from Belinda

Loot Nicholas Timmins

Letter to Nigel from Tom

Loot Gavin's friend

Letter to Pa

Loot a KKK member

Letter to the Editor

"American Dreams" stranger mission

Meeting Notes

Loot a KKK member

Murfree Brood Prisoner's Note

Loot a hanged person

Murfree Brood Ransom Note

Loot a hanged person

Night Folk Victim's Note

Loot a hanged person

Night Folk Wagerer's Note

Loot a hanged person

Wild Man's Journal

Kill the wolf after the Feral Man cave encounter

Fisherman's Hat

Knock Jeremy Gill's hat off before his quest

Liberty Hat

Worn by an enemy or a hogtied man

Native American Ring

Loot a drunk campfire man

Flaco's Revolver

Loot Flaco after his gunslinger duel

Granger's Revolver

Loot Granger after his gunslinger duel

Midnight's Pistol

Loot Midnight after his gunslinger duel

Ornate Dagger

Loot the Vampire

Rare Shotgun

Loot the Hermit northwest of Annesburg

Bill Williamson — Coach Robbery

Javier Escuella — Fishing

Kieran Duffy — Fishing

Micah Bell — Five Finger Fillet

Sean MacGuire — Coach Robbery

Sean MacGuire — Home Robbery

Tilly Jackson — Dominoes

Letter to Angelo Bronte

Mine Share

"Magicians for Sport"

Money Lending and Other Sins IV

The Course of True Love I-III

Covers this package's "the-course-of-true-love-1-2" and "the-course-of-true-love-3" mission entries

Gold Shield

Rare Rolling Block Rifle

Loot a bounty hunter during "Magicians for Sport"

Lion's Paw

After "He's British, of Course IV"

Anthony Foreman

Unavailable in the Epilogue if killed during "No, No and Thrice, No"

Charles Smith — Bank Robbery

Special/Ultimate Edition content

Lenny Summers — Coach Robbery

Micah Bell — Coach Robbery

Simon Pearson — Hunting

Uncle — Rustling

Letter to Bronte from Mayor

"The Gilded Cage"

List of Accounts

"Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten"

Telegram to Police Chief Lamber

"Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten"

Theatre Ticket

"The Gilded Cage"

Brothers and Sisters, One and All

Fatherhood and Other Dreams I & II

Help a Brother Out

Money Lending and Other Sins V

Electric Chair Blueprint

"The Mercies of Knowledge" stranger mission

The Mercies of Knowledge I-VII

Inventor's Note

"A Bright Bouncing Boy" stranger mission

Inventor's Plan

"A Bright Bouncing Boy" stranger mission

Calloway's Revolver

Loot Jim Boy during the gunslinger mission after "A Fine Night of Debauchery"

Blue & Yellow Macaw

Great Green Macaw

Rainbow Boa Snake

Red-footed Booby

Red Boa Snake

Source lists this as "Red-Tailed Boa Snake" — no such species exists in the compendium, treated as this package's "Red Boa Snake"

Scarlet Macaw

Sunglow Boa Snake

Sun Hat

Loot an enemy during Guarma missions

Letter from Charlotte

"Charlotte Balfour" stranger mission

The Widow of Willard's Rest

Letter to Tom from Colm

"Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow"

Archaeology for Beginners

Honor, Amongst Thieves

Money Lending and Other Sins VI & VII

Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow I & II

The Course of True Love IV & V

Do Not Seek Absolution I & II

Covers this package's "do-not-seek-absolution-1" and "do-not-seek-absolution-2" mission entries

Of Men and Angels

Owl Feather Trinket

Don't kill anyone during "Archaeology for Beginners"

John's Gambler's Hat

Worn after "Simple Pleasures"

Worn Flat Cap

Worn during "The Wheel"